Laura Tisdall Ebony Mirror: Hang the DJ Is Not A pleased Tale

Author and Historian

A brand new group of Ebony Mirror is present, and therefore means it is time for my TV that is once-yearly post!

WARNING: This post contains major spoilers for the Ebony Mirror Season 4 episode ‘Hang the DJ’. It and don’t want to be spoiled, do not read this post if you haven’t seen.

‘Hang the DJ’ has been gotten as this season’s ‘San Junipero’, a feel-good episode of ebony Mirror where both the protagonists together with audience get to go back home delighted. Unlike ‘San Junipero’, nevertheless, no one is apparently doubting this reading of this episode. Writer Charlie Brooker clearly commented from the ending: ‘I think it’s a really pleased momentthey are destined to have a very serious relationship and they’re each others’ chosen ones’… they know. Nonetheless, just how do

two protagonists arrive at the true point if they realise they’ve found their ‘chosen one’? And it isn’t that idea by itself notably distressing?

Amy and Frank meet employing a dating application. We ver quickly become mindful that this will be a software with a big change. Not merely is every thing arranged ahead of time when it comes to two of them – through the meals they consume towards the driverless automobile that comes to whisk them away to a romantic, secluded cottage – they’re told through the start that there’s a 12 hour time period limit on the relationship.

… that will be where in fact the Ebony Mirror twist kicks in. We learn that every thing Amy and Frank went through is definitely certainly one of a lot of variations for the simulation that is same. While they meet eyes in a club when you look at the real life, they’re informed by the software they have 99.8% compatibility while they thought we would escape together in 998 away from 1000 simulations. We’re left to think that the application ran dozens of simulations in a portion of an additional, and today Amy and Frank are certain that, in real world, they need to be together.

But, in my experience, this does not feel just like an easy, pleased ending, although it is definitely a whole lot more positive when compared to a complete lot of Ebony Mirror conclusions. Many clearly, it simply comes back us towards the concern the episode initially poses: can an application, nonetheless advanced, really anticipate who you really are ‘destined to be with’? Can there be any anyone you will be ‘destined to be with’ when you look at the beginning, and, no matter if there is certainly, could a software that throws a number of other facets in to the mix understand that without a doubt? What about if for example the One real Love won’t break guidelines under any circumstances? (Although, we enjoyed the sideswipe this episode offers towards the protagonists of bad YA speculative fiction, that are so frequently presented as super special for bold to rebel, by emphasising that rebellion these days is a boringly typical incident.) Amy and Frank appear to be embarking on the same journey because they did in the beginning, albeit with far more dating software that is sophisticated.

Next, given how consistently Black Mirror has portrayed electronic replicas as residing

thinking, sentient beings, is not it horrific to place your own personal electronic replicas through countless mockeries of the life?

Thirdly, i must admit that I’m certainly not up to speed using the notion of A ebony Mirror episode with a totally pleased ending. We argued in my own writeup on ‘San Junipero’ that the episode’s innovation ended up being to provide a happy ending to two homosexual ladies, as this so seldom takes place in fiction. The exact same argument can’t be manufactured for a heterosexual few, which is the reason why comparisons to ‘San Junipero’ notably skip the point. If we’re designed to read ‘Hang The DJ’ as totally pleased, i believe it falls flat; but, if we’re permitted to leave it using the questions I’ve outlined above playing on our minds, i believe it ranks among the most readily useful episodes of the significantly disappointing fourth period.